Bravo host Andy Cohen turned it up a notch on Watch What Happens Live when he brought up a spicy NSFW topic during a recent segment.
The charismatic TV personality asked his WWHL guest bartender John Hill, who also happens to be his musical theater star and radio host ex–to list five “Things Andy Should Do in 2025.” Among the 5 things, John shared that Andy should “release their sex tape from 2003” in the number three spot. John’s suggestion elicited much laughter from the talk show host, and his guests Real Housewives of Beverly Hills star Erika Jayne and upcoming Real Housewives of New York City star Racquel Chevremont.
"Wait, I kind of want to see it? Is it fun?," Erika admitted, with Racquel jokingly adding, "Can we pull it up?"
After Andy got back into hosting mode, he shared, "You know what, I think there is one," warning that "the format, it's on some janky format." John agreed that it was “bad.” Andy was thankful that the antiqueness of the tape prevented it from being circulated.
“We probably can't even transfer it,” Andy said. "Yes we can!" Erika insisted before John moved on to what else Andy should do in the new year.
John has appeared in Broadway productions such as Hairspray and Off-Broadway musicals like Bare: A Pop Opera. As of now, he’s a producer for WWHL and the host of The John Hill Show on Andy’s SiriusXM channel.
Andy and John dated in the early aughts for three years, and have addressed their past romance during John’s past appearances on the Bravo program. During an episode of WWHL that aired in March, Andy revealed that his go-to karaoke tune was John Denver’s Take Me Home, Country Roads.
John wasted no time reminding Andy, "You stole it from me, but it’s yours now."
Andy confessed, "I did steal that from you, oh my God. That's what happens when you let your ex-boyfriend be behind the bar. He calls you out on everything."They also tackled their past sex tape. During John’s The Feels Live show that was
in 2020, Andy noted, "There is a sex tape of us floating around somewhere."
