Andy Cohen just gave a whole new risqué meaning to watch what happens live!
On Tuesday night’s edition of his Bravo late-night talk show, Cohen confirmed he and his ex-boyfriend John Arthur Hill – who co-host Radio Andy together – have a raunchy home video from when they dated more than two decades ago.
Come on Andy, open the vault!
How about we take this to the next level?
Subscribe to our newsletter for a refreshing cocktail (or mocktail) of LGBTQ+ entertainment and pop culture, served up with a side of eye-candy.
The admission came as the hunky former Broadway actor was the night’s guest bartender and during a segment was tasked to list the “top 5 things” Cohen should do in 2025.
After humorously saying the 56-year-old Real Housewives kingpin should “get t*ts” and “finally learn how to read,” Hill unleashed the X-rated bombshell about their intimate relationship.
“Release our sex tape from 2003,” the 46-year-old said matter-of-factly.
The unexpected response delivered a loud reaction of support from the night’s guests, Real Housewives of Beverly Hills star Erika Girardi and Real Housewives of New York City‘s lesbian newbie Racquel Chevremont.
While Cohen seemed shocked, he didn’t deny the adult video’s existence but admitted it might be difficult to watch because it’s probably still in an antiquated form like VHS.
“You know what, I think there is one,” Cohen said. “But the format, it’s on some janky format. I’m glad, we probably can’t even transfer it.”
Meanwhile, Hill gave his own assessment of their bedroom romp by adding: “it’s bad.”
We’ll be the judge of that guys!
Cohen and Hill dated for about three years at the turn of the century and have previously shared details of their relationship.
Back in 2020, Cohen made an appearance at one of Hill’s cabaret shows and not only gave insight into their breakup but also mentioned the existence of their intimate home video, per Bravo.
“There is a sex tape of us floating around somewhere,” Cohen told the audience, before Hill responded to a question about what led to the demise of their romance.
“It was just time,” Hill noted, while Cohen added: “We were in different places in our lives.”
Prior to working with Cohen, Hill was part of the national tour of Broadway’s Miss Saigon. In 2002, he originated the role of Fender in the original Broadway production of Hairspray, alongside Marissa Jaret Winokur, Harvey Fierstein, and Matthew Morrison.
The following year, Hill joined Hugh Jackman in the original Broadway production of The Boy From Oz. In addition to originating the role of Judy Garland‘s ex-husband Mark Herron, he understudied for Jackman’s role of Peter Allen.
Hill’s television credits also include stints producing Project Runway, Love Connection, Martha & Snoop’s Potluck Party Challenge, and the gay train wreck that was Logo’s The A-List: Dallas.
While we’ll probably never see his tape with Cohen, it’s clear Hill has a very impressive, erm, resumé.
If you’re in NYC, check out Hill’s latest cabaret show at The Green Room 42 on Saturday, January 11th.
Sign up for the Queerty newsletter to stay on top of the hottest stories in LGBTQ+ entertainment, politics, and culture.
