JoThe 4 Nations Face-Off has assembled some of the greatest players from across the globe. But one very prominent absence from Team USA has sparked eyebrows. Veteran defender John Carlson, known for his storied career and personal accolades, wasn’t named to the team, even as he’s had a season to remember with the Washington Capitals. The future hall famer’s absence has prompted questions from both fans and pundits.
Carlson recently recorded an immense milestone, reaching his 700th career point with the Washington Capitals. His stature as one of the greatest players in the game is further reinforced by the fact that he is only the 13th defender ever to have accomplished this while playing for just one franchise. It put him alongside an exclusive list of the greatest players ever. Carlson also tops the list as the Caps’ franchise leader in games played, goals, assists, and points among defensemen.
Despite these accolades, Team USA chose not to select Carlson to join them for the 4 Nations Face-Off. Having gained a reputation as a power-play mainstay, consistent two-way defender, and one of the best players under pressure, the decision has raised eyebrows. Some argue that his leadership and expertise would have been invaluable in an otherwise star-studded field, while others believe the team is shifting toward an aggressive, younger defensive squad.
The snub comes as especially baffling considering John Carlson’s past performances representing Team USA internationally. Carlson played both crucial offense and consistent defense during the 2014 Winter Games as well as the 2016 World Cup of Hockey. Having played so impressively internationally, it appears inexplicable that Carlson did not find himself included in the squad.
John Carlson’s legacy is secured, but not fully appreciated
John Carlson has quietly built one of the greatest careers among American defensemen. His contributions, though, are not only limited to statistics; his leadership as an alternate captain has played an invaluable role in defining the team. A central figure in the Capitals’ Stanley Cup win in 2018, Carlson led all defensemen in playoff points, with 20.
Even among active players, his records are exceptional. He is one of only six active NHL defenders over the 700-point mark, alongside Brent Burns, Erik Karlsson, and Kris Letang. Furthermore, he has been an important part of the Capitals’ dominance this season.
With the 4 Nations Face-Off being an audition for the 2026 Games, this snub calls into question whether Carlson gets one final opportunity to suit up for Team USA. Carlson may find himself relegated to watching the Winter Olympics from afar if Team USA continues to prioritize youth over experience
While Team USA has an incredibly talented squad, losing an experienced playmaking defender such as Carlson may cost them significantly in close competition. Having an experienced, consistent presence on the back line would only be a benefit.
The leadership, power play ability, and playoff expertise that John Carlson offers are not easy to replace. For now, Carlson will rest up for the Capitals’ remaining games and prepare himself for their postseason run. Perhaps Team USA will come to regret their decision, or maybe they won’t, but for now, the team looks to be in a good position even without Carlson.
