Did Carl Radke “cheat” on Lindsay Hubbard amid their since-ended engagement last summer?
During Wednesday’s episode of Summer House, Lindsay suspected just that after her 40-year-old ex’s former flame, artist Lil Aronoff, told her co-star and friend, Gabby Prescod, 34, at Carl’s Soft Bar event that she had met him the previous summer.
“He met, like, my whole family cause my dad always goes to NYCFC games, and they became like buddies. And then I slid into his DMs,” Lil revealed, explaining how the two of them met as Carl mingled elsewhere.
Then, Gabby asked, “That was last summer, right?” Lil confirmed, “Yes.”
But it wasn’t last summer.
As Lil has since clarified on her Instagram Story, her first DM was sent to Carl on October 21, 2023, at 7:12 p.m., about two months after he and Lindsay broke up.
“Hi!!! My mom just met you at NYCFC [tonight] and you met my sisters (red hair) a few weeks ago. I am a brunette,” she had written in the message to the Bravolebrity.
Lil also explained in a caption, “Hey hey!!!! [I don’t know] who taught y’all your months, but when I learned them in school, October comes AFTER August!!! xo.”
Lil went on to note that she “[owes you] nothing” as she posted another screenshot of their interaction.
On Wednesday’s Summer House, after Gabby came to her with the information about Lil and her supposed summer DMs with Carl, Lindsay recalled a suspicious moment between them pre-split.
“I went into his room, gave him a hug, and on his phone, he had a DM open where somebody was sending their phone number,” Lindsay shared. “He swiped out of the DM immediately so that I wouldn’t see. So, now it’s, like, all making sense to me.”
Lindsay then shaded Carl for taking on “the victim” role and painting her as a “villain.”
“Meanwhile, b*tch, you’ve been talking to a girl since before you broke up with me,” she ranted. “So you are, once again, gaslighting everyone, manipulating everyone. You’re a f*cking fraud, you’re a phony, you’re a liar, and now I’m adding cheater to your f*cking resume.”
