Lil Aronoff Breaks Silence on Carl Radke Fling, Shares Screenshots to Clear the Air tram

Carl Radke’s season 9 Summer House flame Lil Aronoff broke her silence over their relationship timeline — and she has receipts.

“Hey hey!!!! Idk who taught y’all your months, but when I learned them in school, October comes AFTER August!!! Xo,” Lil wrote via her Instagram Story on Thursday, April 3.

She also shared a screenshot of her initial Instagram DM with Carl, 40, and the date, which read, “October 21 at 7:12 p.m.”

At the time, Lil messaged the Summer House star saying, “Hi!!! My mom just met you at NYCFC tn and you met my sisters (red hair) a few weeks ago. I am a brunette.”

In a second Instagram Story, Lil wrote, “Owe u nothing but here u go xo,” and once again pointed out the date when she first slid into Carl’s DMs. This time the screenshot showed the full date as October 21, 2023.

She added a photo of a girl carrying a cup of tea, seemingly hinting that she was spilling some tea after being dragged into Carl and Lindsay Hubbard’s drama this season. (Fans first met Lil during the cast’s pirate party in the Hamptons, which filmed in July 2024.)\

Lil’s receipt display comes one day after Lindsay, 38, claimed during the Wednesday, April 2, episode of Summer House that Lil and Carl had been messaging before Carl called off their engagement in August 2023.

“He met, like, my whole family because my dad always goes to NYCFC games. Then they became buddies,” Lil said of how she met Carl during the episode, which was filmed during summer 2024. “And then I slid into his DMs.”

Gabby Prescod was instantly suspicious of the timeline, asking, “That was last summer right?” Lil didn’t say anything, but when Imrul Hassan asked, “The NYCFC games?” Lil replied, “Oh, yes, yes, yes.”

Imurl then clarified, “So he’s kinda known you for a year at least,” which Lil said was correct.

“Last summer? When Lindsay and Carl were still very much engaged, he met your parents and then you slid into his DMs? That’s suspicious,” Gabby, 34, told the cameras after the exchange.

Later in the episode, Gabby downloaded Lindsay on her conversation with Lil, which led Lindsay to believe Carl might’ve been unfaithful to her when they were engaged. (Carl broke up with Lindsay in August 2023, one year after proposing.)

“There was one morning the last week of us being together. After the soccer game and before we broke up,” Lindsay recalled during the episode, remembering Carl’s alleged actions in August 2023. “I went into his room, gave him a hug and on his phone, he had a DM open where somebody was sending their phone number. He swiped out of the DM immediately. … Now it’s all making sense to me.”

Lindsay, who has since moved on with boyfriend Turner Kufe, claimed that Carl telling people he hadn’t “moved on” since their breakup was false based on his connection with Lil. (Lindsay and Kufe welcomed their first baby, daughter Gemma, in December 2024.)

“Bitch, you’ve been talking to a girl since before you broke up with me. So, you are once again gaslighting everyone, manipulating everyone,” Lindsay alleged. “You’re a f***ing fraud, you’re a phony, you’re a liar and now I’m adding cheater to your f***ing resume.”

Lindsay later told Paige DeSorbo and Lexi Wood that Carl was messaging Lil in August 2023, claiming, “He went to that soccer game. [Then] they start DMing each other before he ever broke up with me.”

She vowed to confront Carl later, which Bravo teased would take place on the next episode of Summer House. Carl, meanwhile, hasn’t publicly responded to Lindsay’s allegations or Lil defending him.